Downloading vs Recording: What is the Difference | Offline Streaming
Summary: Currently, the common methods for offline viewing include downloading and recording, what are the differences between them? How do users differentiate between these two types of tools when selecting them? This article provides you with some information to assist in this matter.
I’m just an everyday user who saves lots of online classes, live meetings, and, yes, movies. Over the last year I wandered down a few wrong paths trying to legally keep streams—botched downloads, fuzzy video, subtitles gone AWOL.
Many similar users on Reddit and Quora have shared the same frustrations, such as: "Is downloading better, or is screen recording more reliable?" and "Are there any compliant ways to keep both the original audio and subtitles?" These are the core issues this article aims to discuss.
Methods for Offline Streaming
Currently, there are 2 common methods for saving streaming media videos:
- Video downloading mode: Copy content from video websites and streaming platforms to local hard drives.
- Screen recording mode: To "capture in real-time" the currently playing video and audio using software.
So, what are the specific differences (quality, efficiency, etc.) between these two methods, and what are their respective advantages and disadvantages? How to choose the right tool for yourself?
Downloading Method
Download mode is currently divided into two types technically, the difference lies only in the decryption method and the generation of the files:
1. Download + DRM Decryption
The products represented by StreamFab and Anystream are both designed to download original encrypted video streams from streaming platforms directly, decrypt DRM protection, and ultimately produce clear video files, which even makes them the winner of streaming quality vs. StreamFab downloads (or other similar software), on certain streaming services.
1. Fast download speed: The download speed is completely dependent on the user's bandwidth and the response speed of the user and the streaming platform server, such as Amazon. With a good bandwidth, the download speed can reach 30-50 MB/s.
2. Lossless video & audio quality: It is in lossless native quality and completely consistent with the quality provided by the streaming service platform.
3. Subtitle format: Supports a variety of subtitle output formats, such as Remux and external subtitle files.
4. High-quality audio and video formats: When streaming on a browser, streaming service platforms do not support 4K, HDR, Atmos, and other higher-quality playback. However, with some technical means, users can download them.
1. Download + CDM Decryption
Think of it like this: CleverGet grabs the encrypted stream first, then runs it through the CDM to decrypt, caches that clean video, and—after some encode-decode shuffling—spits out Clear video files.
1. Subtitle format: Supports a variety of subtitle output formats, including Remux and external subtitle files.
1. Compatibility: Every streaming site is its own puzzle; you’ll need deep digging, so only a handful are truly supported.
2. Video and audio quality: It’s softer than straight “download” mode.
3. High-quality video formats: Lack of support for superior video formats, such as Netflix HDR, Dolby Vision.
4. Slow CDM decryption speed: It decrypts by decoding frames, spitting out YUV, then re-encoding that YUV back again. (StreamFab skips the decoding and encoding process to directly obtain the final video data, offering a much faster speed).
5. Re-encode files: The speed of generating re-encoded files depends on the user's computer hardware configuration, such as whether the user has a dedicated graphics card (for example, a 2-hour movie):
- 1060 CUDA hardware acceleration: 10~15 mins
- CPU Only: 1.5~2 hours
Record Mode
From the perspective of competitive technologies, the recording mode includes two methods:
1. Traditional Screen Recorders
Streaming recorders, in a general sense, refers to desktop products that allow users to capture the content they desire according to their needs. The content captured mirrors what is seen during playback.
>> Here is a sample recorded by traditional screen recorder, which appears black screen:
Compared to the download mode, streaming is more versatile, not limited to a specific website.
1. Slow recording speed: Only capable of recording at 1x speed, which means that the longer the video duration, the more time it will take to record.
2. Uncertain recorded content: During the recording process, there may be some unnecessary content recorded, such as lag during playback, advertisements, or other pop-ups.
3. Uncertain output quality: The quality of the recorded video is necessarily related to the following two points:
- The quality of the streaming media itself, if the streaming media can only be played at 480p, then even if the recording software outputs 1080p video, it will still be of poor quality.
- Screen recording software technology & file encoding methods. Recording is lossy.
4. Audio quality: Basically can only be AAC 2.0 audio, P.S. any product advertising the ability to record Atmos or EAC3 audio is fake.
5. Subtitle format: Subtitles can only be in render format.
6. Compatibility: Although the video can be seen when streaming is non-DRM protected content, streaming platforms can use certain techniques to prevent recording or display a black screen during playback.
2. Player Recording
This method involves intercepting the cache data of the player in the browser to achieve the purpose of recording videos. Typical methods include Audials and Play On.
>> Here is a sample recorded by Playon:
1. Offering a more compatible support for streaming sites
2. It supports high-speed recording.
3. Skip ads during recording
1. Speed slow: Compared to screen recording, Player Recording allows for accelerated recording, such as 2x, 5x speed.
2. High resource consumption: During the recording, files are generated simultaneously, leading to high system resource consumption.
3. Audio quality: Usually stuck at AAC 2.0 audio.
4. Video quality: Whatever the browser shows, you get. Quality rides the stream.
5. Subtitle format: Usually in Render format, but with a deeper analysis of streaming media platforms, it is still possible to separate video and subtitles during the recording process, supporting Remux or external subtitle formats.
How to Define Downloading or Recording?
How can one distinguish whether a certain product is in download or recording mode?
- The functional introductions of each product's product page
- From the perspective of resource utilization
- Download mode occupies less CPU or GPU resources, usually less than 20%
- Recording mode occupies higher CPU or GPU resources, typically above 30%
- During the recording mode, there is usually a video encoding and decoding process, which can be distinguished by checking the resource utilization in the task manager during recording:
And here's the overall comparison between downloading and recording.
| Downloaders | Downloading | Recording |
|---|---|---|
| Video Quality |
|
|
| Audio Tracks |
Multiple tracks supported, retains original quality (e.g., 5.1, Dolby Atmos) |
Typically, only the current track, rarely multi-audio, quality depends on the device |
| Subtitles |
All embedded/external subtitles, multi-language, can be extracted/edited/switched |
Only visible subtitles (“burned-in”), can’t extract or switch |
| Difficulty |
Needs resources/tools, may require subscription/payment, platform restrictions |
Just install recording software, low barrier, fewer tech limitations |
| Speed |
|
|
| A/V Sync |
Native sync, no audio/video out-of-sync issues |
Risk of sync issues if the system is overloaded |
Final Words
The above is all the information regarding the differences between downloading and recording modes. We strive to express technical knowledge in simple and understandable language. Take Twitch as an example, if you want to save Twitch streams from a channel’s past broadcasts, downloading is faster and tidier; if you’re grabbing a Twitch Live in the moment, recording is the way to go.
Still deciding between video downloaders, or feeling muddled about record vs. download? Same. I’ve been there, coffee in hand, twelve tabs open. Hopefully this clears the fog. And if you only need the sound, you can also download audio from website quickly and safely.
